Post Comment

Name:

Email:

Comment:


Twitter
Facebook
You Tube
Blog
Forum
undefined
Trustpilot
Contact us Wishlist Support Blog
Account
Login or sign up
Personal details Payment details My delivery addresses My orders Return an item Check return status
Basket
Basket Updating...

Gaming PCs

Reign Gaming PCs

All Reign Gaming PCs NVIDIA RTX Gaming PCs AMD Ryzen Gaming PCs Intel Gaming PCs PCs by Game VR Ready Gaming PCs Next Day Gaming PCs

Reign Scout Gaming PCs

1080p Gaming

Reign Sentry Gaming PCs

1440p & 4K Gaming

Reign Vanguard Gaming PCs

4K Gaming & Content Creation

Desktop PCs

Custom PCs

Configure an Intel PC Configure an AMD PC View all

Home PCs

Intel Home PCs AMD Home PCs View all

Office PCs

Intel Office PCs Mini Office PCs View all
Browse our range of next day PCs, in-stock and ready for delivery

Workstations

Workstations by Use

All Workstations Media & Entertainment Architectural, Engineering & Construction Manufacturing & Product Design Deep Learning Forensics Multi-Monitor Rackmount

Filter by Technology

Intel Core Processors Intel Xeon Processors AMD Ryzen Processors AMD EPYC Processors NVIDIA GeForce RTX Graphics NVIDIA Quadro Graphics AMD Radeon Pro Graphics

Custom Workstations

All Custom Workstations Custom Intel Core Workstation Custom Intel Core X Workstation Custom Intel Xeon E Workstation Custom Intel Xeon W Workstation Custom Intel Xeon Scalable Workstation Custom Dual Intel Xeon Scalable Workstation Custom AMD Ryzen Workstation Custom AMD Ryzen Threadripper Workstation Custom AMD EPYC Workstation

Servers

Tower Servers

All Tower Servers Intel Xeon E-series Intel Xeon Scalable AMD EPYC

Rackmount Servers

All Rackmount Servers Intel Atom Intel Xeon E-series Intel Xeon Scalable

Storage Servers

All Storage Servers All Flash Array JBODs

GPU Servers

All GPU Servers NVIDIA DGX AMD EPYC

Laptops

Category

Everyday use Mobile Workstations Pro

Use

Home Business Gaming

Laptop Extras

Adapters Accessories Batteries

More

All Laptops Laptop Repairs Carepack Information Clearance Laptops Repairs

Monitors

Type

All Monitors NVIDIA G-SYNC AMD FreeSync 4K UHD 32:9 Ultrawide 21:9 Ultrawide

Refresh Rate

240Hz 165Hz 144Hz

Size

28"+ 27" 24" 21.5" to 22" 19.5" to 20" 18" to 19"

Monitor Accessories

All Monitor Accessories Monitor Mounts Monitor Stands Privacy Filters Screen Cleaning Audio & Video Cables
Check out our Monitor offers here

Peripherals

Keyboards

All Keyboards Gaming Keyboards Mechanical Keyboards Wired Keyboards Wireless Keyboards Keyboard Accessories Keyboard & Mouse Bundles

Mice

All Mice Gaming Mice Wired Mice Wireless Mice Mouse Mats Keyboard & Mouse Bundles

Other Input Devices

All Input Devices Gamepads Joysticks & Flight Control Steering Wheels Graphics Tablets

Audio & Visual

Headsets Gaming Headsets PC Speakers Microphones Webcams Projectors & Accessories

Gaming Chairs & Desks

Gaming Chairs Gaming Desks

Printing

Printer Cartridges

PDU & Surge Protection

View All

Components

Graphics Cards

Top Graphics Card Deals NVIDIA Graphics Cards AMD Graphics Cards NVIDIA RTX Series NVIDIA GTX Series Professional Graphics

Processors

All Processors Intel Processors AMD Processors Thermal Paste

Memory

All Memory DDR4 Memory DDR3 Memory Laptop Memory

Motherboards

Top Motherboard Deals All Motherboards Intel Motherboards AMD Motherboards

Power Supplies

Top PSU Deals All PSUs Modular PSUs Non-Modular PSUs PSU Cables

Cases

Top Case Deals All Cases Full Tower Cases Mid Tower Cases Mini ITX Cases Mini Tower Cases Rackmount Cases Case Accessories Case Cables

PC Cooling

Top PC Cooling Deals All-in-one Watercoolers Open-Loop Watercooling CPU Coolers Case Fans

Part built Bundles

Intel Barebone Bundles Intel Motherboard Bundles AMD Barebone Bundles AMD Motherboard Bundles

Other Components

Sound Cards Optical Drives Clearance Components

Storage & Networking

SSD / Solid State Drives

All SSDs M.2 NVMe SSDs M.2 NVMe Gen 4 SSDs

Hard Drives

All Hard Drives All 3.5" Desktop Hard Drives All 2.5" Desktop Hard Drives SATA Cables

Other Storage

External SSDs External Hard Drives Flash Memory USB Memory Sticks Clearance Storage

Wireless Networking

All Wireless Wireless Routers Wireless Extenders Wi-Fi Adapter Cards

Networking

All Networking Powerlines Network Switches KVM Switches Network Interface Cards Network Cables Clearance Networking

Network Attached Storage

All NAS Solutions Desktop NAS Solutions Rackmount NAS Solutions

Business & Education

Training & Defence

Training & Defence Solutions Rack Integration GPU Solutions Virtualised Environments How we work

AI & Deep Learning

AI & Deep Learning Solutions Technology Platforms Research & Development Proof of concept Proof of concept

Education

Education Solutions Desktops for Education Laptops for Education Google for Education Internet & Safeguarding
Future Proof your
school
Enhanced Fulfillment
Services
Blog Your account Contact & Support
COVID19 and Showroom Collection Information
×
Home | Gaming and esports | Review Bombing – Why does it exist and what can be done?

Review Bombing – Why does it exist and what can be done?

Posted in Gaming and esports

Author - Benjamin Hiorns

Last updated on 30 Nov 2020

TurtleBlaze released their ‘ninja parkour’ platformer, Kunai, on 6th February 2020. Just ten days later the game had an impressive 8.1 User Score on Metacritic along with some great coverage on a bunch of websites.

They must have been feeling pretty good. Indie games can take thousands of hours to make and the work is often done by small teams working long hours. All of that hard work was paying off.

But things took a turn on February 17th, when their Metacritic User Score plummeted from 8.1 to a measly 1.7 in the space of a day.

For those of you who aren’t familiar with Metacritic, that’s a seriously low score on one of the internet’s biggest game review sites. The kind of score that’s going to send players packing and derail your launch.

They could tell they’d been ‘review bombed’, which is when people ruin a game or film’s score on review sites by leaving negative reviews. 

After a bit of digging, they were able to find out how. The review bomber left a post on Reddit explaining how he did it. The post has since been taken down but you can see a screengrab below.

Novatech - Review Bombing

It wasn’t a personal vendetta. It wasn’t even someone who played the game. 

It was a random attack by a lone wolf who wanted to show how Metacritic’s review policy left developers exposed. Turtleblaze were in the wrong place at the wrong time. 

Unfortunately, they’re just one of many developers, large and small, who have had their games review bombed. But why do people do this? And what can be done to stop them?

Why do people review bomb games?

People review bomb games and films for all kinds of reasons. Some of them more laudable than others. 

To make their voices heard

For some people, review bombing a game or a film is a way of voicing their opinion.

The Last of Us 2 was review bombed heavily after its release. The effects are still visible today. The game has a glowing Critic Score of 93 on Metacritic, but a User Score of just 5.7, which is suspiciously low for a game that won Ultimate Game of the Year at the Golden Joystick Awards 2020.

Granted, some of the negative reviews were related to the game itself. We won’t post the comments here for fear of spoilers, but you can find an explanation here if you’re interested. 

But some gamers felt that the storyline was too politically charged and criticised the developers for pushing an agenda they didn’t agree with.

A less political example is Astral Chain, which was flooded with 0/10 ratings on its release because it was exclusive to the Nintendo Switch. Gamers without Nintendo Switches punished the developers by leaving brutal reviews on a game that they wanted to play but couldn’t.

To call out flaws in the game

But there is another side to review bombing that’s a bit closer to the purpose of online reviews. Actually, you might wonder whether it’s ‘review bombing’ at all.

After the developers of Fall Guys released their game on Steam, they posted on Twitter that they were getting review bombed.

We're currently being review-bombed on Steam... ??

We're working really hard to get running smoothly for SO MANY players!

We know it's super frustrating, but if you could hold off from negatively reviewing - Until you get chance to play the game, it would really help us out ??

— Fall Guys ?? (@FallGuysGame) August 4, 2020

But when one journalist took a closer look, he found that a lot of the negative reviews were legitimate, either related to server issues or the gameplay itself.

Another example of a big name game that attracted a lot of negative reviews is Bethesda’s Fallout 76, which has a Metacritic User Score of just 2.7. But was this a review bombing, or was it just a disappointing release? The Guardian interviewed one of the review bombers who contributed to Fallout’s low score.

“Let’s be honest,” he said. “If this didn’t have the Fallout title on it, nobody would pay $60 for it. It’s only because it’s related to Fallout and Bethesda that some people even play it.”

So is this review bombing, or just a disappointing game getting the feedback that people feel it deserves? 

Political or random review bombs may be hard to justify. But getting feedback is an important part of any creative process. It’s important to make the distinction between people leaving negative reviews because they have an axe to grind and people leaving negative feedback based on the shortcomings of the game.

What can be done to stop review bombing?

Metacritic has been criticised for allowing review bombing to happen. Specifically, letting people review games without some proof of ownership.

People have also shared other ideas online for how to prevent review bombing from happening in the future:

  • Game ownership can be verified, like it is for users on Steam, which won’t allow users to review games they don’t own.

  • Fake domains used to bomb games need to be automatically blacklisted.

  • Reviews from the same IP address should be flagged as at least suspicious.

  • Accounts should be given a grace period of a week or more before they are allowed to leave a review.

  • Stop letting users review games on the day they are released, which is something Metacritic has actually already instigated.

 

Review bombing is unlikely to go away anytime soon, so it’s going to be up to the review platforms themselves to take steps to reduce it. 

 

If you’d like to learn how Novatech helps games developers of all sizes do their best work, visit our Media & Entertainment services. 

Recent posts

Training & Simulation

20 Jan 2021

How a gamer’s passion grew to provide outstanding visuals for training and simulations

We spoke to Chris Torchia about the unconventional path he took to build Vigilante.

Esports

19 Jan 2021

Reign by Novatech Assembles to Compete in Charity Esports Tournament

Gaming for good: Reign set out to raise money for their chosen charity, Solent Mind, as they enter the Business Esports Charity Tournament.

How To

14 Jan 2021

Office 365 - Where to start? a checklist

You've decided to go with Office 365, it's an excellent choice and has many benefits which are going to help your organisation. But where do you start? It can be a daunting prospect implementing a new system, but have no fear!

Get the latest from Novatech

Signup to our mailing list to get the latest info on deals and events before everyone else. Don't worry, we won't fill your inbox with spam.

Contact Novatech
  • Technical Support
  • Sales
  • Customer Services
  • Our Showroom
  • Get in touch (webmaster)
  • Forum
  • Blog
  • Latest News
About Novatech
  • Careers at Novatech
  • Who we are & What we do
  • Why Buy From Us
  • Trust Pilot Reviews
  • Privacy & Security
  • Novatech & WEEE Regulations
  • Quality & Environmental Policy
  • Modern Slavery Statement
  • COVID-19 Risk Assessment Policy
Your Account
  • Login / Register
  • Track an Order
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy & Security
Services
  • Repairs / Service Centre
  • Affiliates
  • Trading Schemes
  • Payment Methods
  • Finance Options

© Copyright 2000-2021 Novatech Ltd - Computer Supplies | Company Reg No: 2605046 | WSV 8.2.1-JMM - sti

Head Office - Novatech Ltd, Harbour House, Hamilton Road, Cosham, Portsmouth, PO6 4PU

db

We use cookies to provide a better customer experience on our site. By continuing to shop with us, you consent to our use of cookies. Our cookie policy is available here